Is stoicism masculine reddit. If I were to describe me, I’m an emotional dude.

Is stoicism masculine reddit people love seeing the end result of the work of art, whether it be a piece of music or a nice healthy body, but people view the work of obtaining the end result as hard and terrible, boring even. Anyone wanting to increase awareness of themselves or their cause is going to use the words and phrases that get the most attention. As much as I hate to sound cliché, black and Hispanic men are the pinnacle of stoicism and masculine performance Not sure how to sound it out into a coherent thought, but with men of color we're always being portrayed into these bearable bucks who take no shit and society has trained our brains to always work for our singular succeses rather The way I see it is that women get the best of both worlds. I don't think you understand stoic philosophy, its not about being a 99 level sigma male, but appreciating what you have because you could have less. Kind of like the color or your hair or or eyes. Despite the differences between ancient Greece and Rome, and modern societies, some of the Stoic writings indicate that Stoic philosophy was just as useful for women, as for men. This doesn't mean that men should not be allowed to be vulnerable at times, but learning stoicism will benifit your life and mental being. I’m not confident, I’m not rugged, and I’m not stoic. Quotes taken out of context tend to do more harm than good. And just like a follower of stoicism will say that another philosophy is incorrect, other philosophies will say stoicism isn't correct. They do only work as side Characters, teachers or antagonists. If society portrays it that way, thats societys problem. The mature ones are older, more adventurous, and into fancy steakhouses, for example. As a woman with PMDD, I experience pretty intense mood shifts around my monthly cycle. Toxic masculinity is a loaded term. In what way has stoicism ever said you can’t have fun of enjoy life? A large part of stoicism is about happiness. Hormones profoundly affect health and mental functioning. Not exactly emblematic of stoic control. Emotions are usually a result of judgments or beliefs about the world, and the goal of the Stoic would be to reevaluate their beliefs and therefore prevent the negative emotions from ever being felt. It's valid to grieve over a break up, not silly at all. I think there are opposing perspectives, depending on what angle one approaches Stoicism from. An emdr therapist and self proclaimed stoic had me incorporate the Daily Stoic into my journaling and daily palliative care routine. Honor, chivalry, stoicism, bushido, logos, integrity, etc are distinctly masculine male traits. It's maybe not so noticeable in the first book, but I'm at book four and by then the protagonist has become the embodiment of stoicism, basically. (I realize the book has mixed reviews by this sub but idgaf-pop philosophy isn't necessarily a bad thing). I think the biggest mistake people, mostly men, make is to force masculinity. ” To add to this, because this is Reddit and not a masters symposium, a huge number of responders don't know the first thing about gender abolition and just intuit the meaning by googling the individual words. Hence, for the ancient Stoic, there was a cognitive alliance between becoming a Stoic sage and becoming a self-actualized male. I will meet death again. A stoic character has no real "struggels" and has nothing about growth. Be yourself OP. A silent confidence works better than a loud confidence for shorter dudes. There has been confusion due to some elements of the manosphere co-opting an altered interpretation of some elements of the philosophy though. So if you are weak and feminine as a man then by definition you are not a Stoic sage. The traditional expectation for male masculinity seems to fall in line with being confident, rugged, and stoic. I guess that is For a female to reach peak femininity there is a very different scale, not less, not better, just different. Expected norms for masculinity absolutely has room for emotion you only need to look at the retirement of Welsh Rugby legend Shane Williams and the raw emotion during the anthems and the post match interview by everyone - the farewell/ funeral haka for Lomu is also worth a look at if you think men can't be emotional (as an aside My point was that men are especially drawn to Stoicism because it offers them a paradigm by which they can be (masculine, and I don't mean à la Andrew Tate) men and good people. There is a Stoic in that series, and it is Cato the Younger. In essence, it is moving forward in life instead of dwelling on a feeling/situation that would leave you desiring more, sulking, and/or resenting anything in particular. Especially if you're a man. Stoicism the philosophy doesn't teach "shelving memories and experiences without fully dealing with" them. If you think Stoicism is masculine, you probaly didnt understand it. I thought that understanding would be implicit when mentioning Stoicism. I think there’s a parallelism between the vernacular usage of stoic and an aspect of masculinity (toxic masculinity) which states that men should suppress their emotions or that men must be “logical” because women are “emotional” and thus male emotion is bad. I’m curious as to if this effects who does and doesn’t follow stoicism. Or check it out in the app stores Home; Popular By stoic, meaning that you aren't too neuroic or emotional. Justifying stoicism through the lens of stoicism is kind of a pointless task to me because it's just circular. Reading the source texts kind of cuts out the middle-man but can pose more of a challenge (and challenges do aid in learning, but even then there aids like modern translations and commentaries), whereas relying on an author’s interpretation may be easier reading, but things may be left out or added Hello, I am a female to male transgender stoic. By believing that an obstacle is the way (i. She doesn’t like you the way you like her back. If used properly, this can be a positive masculine tool. A lot of people who don’t actually study the philosophy if Stoicism, equate it with the adjective which has little to nothing to do with the philosophy. The Stoic philosophy doesn’t teach indifference, it teaches being knowledgeable of your emotions but not suppression of It isn't easy to summarise precisely why as the Stoic notion of cosmopolitanism is one a new student will need time to fully define, but I will tell you that if you could demonstrate that Stoicism was in any way "male", you'd have disproven the entire philosophy's validity. Now it is fantasy if you enjoy that genre. Etc You telling him this as a hard truth would be a masculine thing to do, him taking a hard look at himself and setting aside his ego and responding to your advice instead of getting angry or reactive, is masculine Likewise the female has the same senses as the male; namely sight, hearing, smell, and the same senses as the male; namely sight, hearing, smell, and the others. Idealized characteristics,but nonetheless gender coded. I'd say to an important extent Stoicism (as well as virtue ethics in general and psychological therapies derived from it, mainly Cognitive Behavioural Therapy) is based on changing your own habits of thought, mainly by learning to manage your expectations and emotions (just in case, obviously this does not mean supressing them, it means 609K subscribers in the Stoicism community. It is a slow burn but the male character, who is a demon, is not allowed to show love or emotion. However, when I think of "emotional labor" as a specific phrase/concept, I think of something different. It oozes purpose. I am a woman, and I too believe gender to be a stoic indifferent, just as is pretty much everything physical. This is convoluted with the notion of being emotionally stoic being an important trait for masculine men. You learn that you can only control your actions and if other people are frustrated in their own lives and take it out on video game while you are trying to win, you learn to understand and move on. We can overlook “like a woman” being used as a negative in order to benefit from the meat of the philosophy. Gender identity was then, as now, pretty fundamental to one's 'natural' state. Stoicism is focused on reason, using reason to address emotions, life events, character development. Most women like someone who’s true to their feelings; most don’t even like the modern “stoic male” stereotype. Well, stoicism is an emotionally difficult task that some people feel compelled to undertake on behalf of others. A man can live in solitude for years in nature. Stoicism in itself doesn't provide you happiness, but rather increases the "floor" of this happiness spectrum. Stoicism is an ancient Western philosophy of personal ethics that teaches the path to personal happiness is accepting things as they are rather than how we want them to be(1). The amount of Stoicism it helps you practice is insane. It is gender related because in society things like stoicism,strength and being unyielding is pretty much male characteristics. I go absolute nuts when i feel that im lonely and i want to control it. It provides direction so that you are not controlled by your emotions - a philosophy of managi Be the first to comment Nobody's responded to this post yet. You should listen to some stotic teachings from the greek on youtube, to get a better picture of what im saying. A 'get-wise quick' title followed by that first sentence. The better you are at incorporating stoicism into your life, the less those negative events will affect you. You're looking at Romance novels. Take this as an opportunity to learn to deal with this rejection in a healthy way. Stoicism is the antidote to toxic masculinity because often its toxic emotions combined with the masculine strength that can lead to aggression. "Oh I got yelled at/I'm broke/family member died so I should be resilient bc I can't change it so I shouldnt care" is a common and fucked up interpretation of stoicism. Love the quote because it embodies a core stoic principle - Amor Fati - where you love and embrace what ever happens to you. Posted by u/[Deleted Account] - 4 votes and 6 comments Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now AI images used in YouTube Stoic quotes videos are not masculine enough and need to be both more Also, if you're a Stoic, you probably aren't just looking for the easy approach). The ideals of modern day masculinity aren't traits you will find in stoic teachings. He’s stoic in the newer English understanding of the word on that he does not emote, but that is not being Stoic, representing the philosophy. So I can see where you're coming from. My Mother is very similar, she was a very Stoic women in regards to taking care of the house, feeding her kids, doing what had to be done to make sure we were safe and well. Exceptions to the statistical differences between men and women, like transgender people, more often prove the rules than refute I think what it means to be “masculine” tends to be biased by toxic, boisterous qualities, and misconstrues or totally overlooks other really healthy, important qualities. The basis being how many stoics we would have without the ideals. Probably because less informed people confuse stoicism with completely shutting of your emotions, which is generally considered as "toxic masculinity" This makes me wonder if men are over represented in stoicism due to the masculine ideal, or if women are under represented due to the feminine ideal. The latter is a gross oversimplification and misrepresentation of the philosophy, which is more about being a good person than mastering emotions and enduring hardship. I would contend that Stoic teaching transcends all differences between people. You can be a good man irrespective of how masculine (or not) you are, simply by being a good person. Stoicism is quite vulnerable here though, because the academic literature on Stoicism is so recent. So this is nothing new and it's out there and for good reason. For example, one of the surviving lectures of Musonius Rufus, who was the teacher of Epictetus, is titled That women too should study philosophy . Scarlett it's a series of 4 books. Part of my Stoic practice (as a newbie) is writing down any time I behave badly due to letting my emotions drive my The stoic ones are traditionally masculine but look reserved, like this guy. Stoic are a very small part society so why care what they think. Many people have given you concrete answers and you’re still trying to justify it Have as much sex as you like, stoicism believes in self mastery. If I were to describe me, I’m an emotional dude. Stoic philosophers like Musonius Rufus did oppose arbitrarily treating the sexes differently, but a lot of us enjoy culturally constructed institutions which play on the statistical differences between the sexes. Stoicism isn't merely about working hard or being tough. I don't want to give away too much! The "Hard Luck Hank" series actually has a protagonist that becomes more and more stoic with every book. Stoicism is acknowledging that you feel a certain way (happy, sad, angry, etc) while also accepting reality for what it is. IMHO masculine and famine are character traits that describe people but don't have inherent good or bad. let’s look at some of its characteristics, instead of explaining it as being a man or being masculine. And yeah it does make you wonder what we are looking for doesnt it? It's like the same in any kind of practice or discipline. Nov 21, 2020 · However, the emotional labor of portraying a stoic, masculine ideal is a ticking time bomb for physical and mental distress. Again, I feel like your interpretation of Stoicism is maybe being crossed with the term ‘stoic’. Thing is that stoic virtues are fairly masculine traits , and virtue is strength. A woman that is good at cars and electronics as well as being feminine is like the holy grail of people. To throw some history into this pot, the Latin 'virtus' is directly related to the Latin, 'vir' meaning man, or husband. I am sure that if manufacturers put the word "Stoic" on their hemorrhoidal ointment it would increase sales. Add your thoughts and get the conversation going. Yes but this isn't reddit. com Oct 3, 2024 · Yet, for some reason, Stoicism has often been framed in a masculine light. In what way is stoicism about disconnecting from emotions? In fact this idea of controlling your emotional response to external circumstances is a key part of stoicism. Some parts of that are being able to inspire, support, and listen to others. Also a revenge quest is explicitly contrary to Stoic philosophy. I think Stoicism is no more geared towards men than it is geared towards the Greeks or Romans (or Italians in general, or even Europeans). All big stoic philosophers may have been men, but thats probaly the case for any ancient philosophy. Why in the world would a Stoic squander their I would say, in reply to OP, and as a gay male, who grew up in a rural conservative Appalachian area, and now is a successful professional and married to my husband happily, Stoicism applies in many areas to many people. Hit 4 months remission this past week, and will turn 32 in a couple of months. com, this is /r/shortguys and you have to be going well out of your way to find this place. This is why stoicism is often thought to be a toxic trait for men. If a woman is unyielding,stoic,etcshe is usually seen as headstrong and unconpromising and a “bad bitch”. As in Post-Classical. Maybe that’s why many stoic “celebrities” are male, because men are more actively seeking stoic principles. Learning Stoicism and Logic: Shouldn’t basic logic be understood before learning stoicism? In readings like Epictetus, people seem to follow the logic, but that doesn't happen with me. Discipline is a form of self mastery. Mostly when it comes to the idea of "calm, logical and masculine" vs "emotional, hysterical and feminine" and in my opinion that distinction is not very logical in itself - which, of course, is also why it's dying out and more seen as an archaic sexist view. , it's part of your journey) you embrace the struggle and love it, it's a part of you. So my approach towards the Self is necessarily from the standpoint of consciousness towards the unconscious. Thanks! In another thread there was some interesting debate about what it means to be masculine. John wick isn’t very stoic. Otherwise the other have provided plenty of current Stoics. Feminists typically take a dim view of masculine behavior. Epictetus - Discourses, Fragments, Handbook translated by Robin Hard is a book containing the lectures of the Stoic teacher Epictetus. For masculine honor it’s just not allowing people to disrespect you, like cutting you in line, calling out a date for her using her phone while talking to her etc. Take cancel culture and if you don't believe it exists think of those that are most active in these endeavors. Let's foster a community that develops virtue together—stay relevant to I wonder if men discover and pursue stoicism more as a means to find peace and deal with rage, whereas many women are already practicing stoics? At least as a general tendency in populations overall. Impressions are the initial thoughts and senses and stoicism is using your rational mind to judge the truth of the impressions and even better withhold judgement of them. Being emotionally unavailable isn’t cool anymore. Stoicism and Masculinity. You can apply everything as a woman too. The irony is strong with this one. Apart from historical circumstances that meant few women practised philosophy in antiquity, I'm not seeing how Stoicism is peculiarly masculine-- especially given that those same historical conditions would mean all philosophy "emerges from masculinity in the first place," making Stoicism unremarkable in that respect, and Stoicism neither more This is because stoicism in some sense emasculates you because you wont have the proper masculine aggression that is needed in situations like defending your honor when you're getting bullied, teased, ridiculed, having your gf getting harassed by men, youre out with your mom and someone touches her etc, your inaction would be the result of your But after you're done crying, you need to examine the events that caused you to feel this way in the first place through a Stoic lens. No, because stoicism is not disassociating. Big-s Stoicism advocates cultivating virtue and correct judgements about situations, so that your emotions are properly measured to situations and your ability to do anything about them. One of the most common gender roles for men is being unemotional However to entertain the question I will say that stoicism is not inherently masculine or feminine but our traditional concepts of men and women may lead some to conclude that stoic virtue is a manly virtue which I agree with but it is manly to me because it embodies what I would like to be as a man. Providing context and effortful elaboration as to a topic’s relevance to the philosophy of Stoicism gives the community a common frame of reference from which to engage in productive discussions. Think of a typical financial analyst on Wall St In the Roman Empire, the time period almost all Stoic writings are from, a significant part of "being masculine" was having gay sex with other men, the traditional garb for a man was a skirt, and you greeted your social and military superiors with a healthy kiss on the lips - what does this say about your idea that what you consider masculine I can’t tell if you’re trolling, but the purpose of stoicism is to live according to your nature, which is virtue. sigma shit is cringe, but it has more to do with a lack of leading male figures in current culture than like, a political lean towards trump or something. Sex/gender is completly irrelevant to stoic wisdom. guts is a pretty good example of stoicism actually, and a lot of gymbros are pretty positive. It’s making correct judgement of impressions. Judging from your replies It seems like you’re looking for a reason to do it and feel justified. That is, without being considered both the aggressor and the victim at the same time, all the time. even down to testosterone and estrogen: men and women have both. Psychologists also strive to reduce male stoicism and self-reliance (mental health stigma for men) by acknowledging and challenging socialized messages related to . Notably, physical strength can be replaced with other forms of strength so long as they are equally as viable in conflict or war. Vein of Love by R. The idea that I found especially resonant to me was finding your own mentors / teachers, or your 'chosen parents'. 580K subscribers in the Stoicism community. Fascism is a very unnatural and immoral ideology that has nothing but death and destruction to offer anyone when viewed on its own merits. both physical genders have masculine and feminine traits in them. Also both have the same parts of the body, and one has nothing more than the other. Also I want to point out that, while the ancient Romans who wrote all the Stoic texts were shockingly sexist by today's standards, the philosophy itself has no opinion on gender roles. Hello guys, as a wannabe stoic male i can conquer most of the stoic principles but one of the things that is hard to me is being self dependent. Learning to accept and move past your emotions doesn't prevent you from experiencing them. on the other hand however, one cannot do much about it, and just 563K subscribers in the Stoicism community. At its heart it is about the human experience, and we all share some similarities and experience some differences. The same characteristics and bravado on a women As a woman who practices stoicism, I see modern day ideas and interpretations masculinity as something that men do to impress other men. A healthy, balanced, virtuous human appreciates both sides and embraces the freedom and It's training the masculine skills of leadership, strength, courage, decisiveness. To me there is nothing "masculine" or "feminine" about it. Stoicism relates to many masculine characteristics. This division is not natural, and we should end it. However some people vilify these traditionally masculine traits favouring more feminine men. Stoicism teaches to examine one's impressions and inner thoughts and reframe them. This is irational and a lack of wisdom. It requires strength to be virtues because it’s hard to act correctly and easy to give into impulse fulled by pleasure. Whereas female brain is actually a lot more complex and with a lot more sense of attachment with everything. Please keep advice, comments, and posts relevant to Stoic philosophy. So, you're not understanding men, stoicism and psychology here. Katanagatari was pretty decent, Shichika was similar to what I'm looking, but I'm leaning more towards nearly emotionless characters. Being controlled by your emotions is like the most stereotypically masculine trait. It could be used as a tool to take the burden and process it when the time is right. well OP did say that they by no means are or trying to be a stoic, but in my view, someone who's recently picked up stoicism, it is certainly frustrating to see, as i perceive it to cause harm to our society, and the environment by which we live affects how we care for ourself. Stoicism is the ancient philosophy that this subreddit aims to discuss, whereas stoicism is common vernacular for being unfeeling and tough or resilient. Stoic the adjective typically is synonymous with ‘indifference’. As you practice stoicism, the scale will increase to 2-10, then 3-10 and so on. In my time exploring stoicism, I find that a lot of stoic values also line up with masculine values. Although some stoics some of the time might be talking about an idealised man the majority of the tradition is really trying to stop people acting out on their not so great instincts. We are a community committed to learning about and applying philosophical Stoic principles and techniques. You can be masculine and virtuous, but you are not virtuous because you are masculine, and obviously there are many who are masculine and vicious, or virtuous and not masculine. The man killed like 100 people because his dog was killed. That means reading books like The Practicing Stoic and if Stoicism seems like it makes sense to you, then move on to the classic works of Epictetus, Seneca and Marcus Aurelius. I don't think Stoicism is mostly geared toward men at all. It’s my vulnerability. Robertson, who is a clinical psychologist and expert on Stoicism has several excellent books about this. The thing about stoic Characters in Media is that they do not work as protagonists. Romance meant inspired by Romanesque literature. The current “broicist” take on Stoicism is very male-centred, but it’s not actual Stoicism. Guys turn to stoicism since not feeling is a masculine legacy, but men take action to solve problems and become stronger and get better providing, protecting, etc. They differ in that Stoicism pursues virtue, while (Mahayana) Buddhism seeks to end suffering for all beings. Stoicism and the Art of Happiness by Donald Robertson is a practical introduction on what Stoicism is and how to implement it in your life. If practicing Stoicism directly limits your ability to act, you're doing it wrong. Thats a dumb caricature or cartoon of its true essence. Edit: Yes, I've noticed the same overlap. Stoicism is the “common sense” philosophy, it fits everywhere. you have internalized some rather harmful notions about masculinity but the good news is that masculinity has been evolving past the brutish primitive view of "what it means to be a man" for some time now. 587K subscribers in the Stoicism community. In fact, Stoicism is probably the most masculine, disciplined and rational philosophy there is. Legions of "masculine" guys are all slaves to their anger, specifically, even the ones I'm sure you would call "stoic". You don’t need validation from other guys. Male stoicism is in fact more typically what we call male normative alexithymia, which is to say it is a deficiency of men rather than a strength. Stoicism is also the name given to emotional repression, particularly when it is presented as a masculine "virtue"(2). From my understanding stoicism tells you that you should not care about things outside of your control and one of those things is your body, you can not change what you were given at birth. One of the main objects for a student of Stoicism is to remove the desire for things they cannot control, and only desire thinsgs up to them. In my opinion stoicism is irrelevant to females, they operate completely differently, not less, not better, just different. It also seems to me that in the past, and possibly present stoicism has had more of an effect of men as well. The largest difference in my non-expert-in-either view is the practices. However Some cons are that it’s impractical and may take something away from people who enjoy identifying with “feminine” and “masculine. I think these folks are taking a wrong interpretation of the word itself, stoic, to mean rigid and strong and without emotion whereas the name Stoicism derives from the Stoa Poikile (Ancient Greek: ἡ ποικίλη στοά), or "painted porch" I'm 5ft7 I've always been a stoic even though I wasn't even aware, as I've got older you learn more and more about the world and about how your perception of yourself is not always the perception others have of you , people concoct all sorts of ideas In there mind due to differences and yes the media the media on height has become quite Thank you for sharing. It's good to hear a woman's opinion on Stoicism, as there is a perception of Stoicism being mostly male (A stereotype that we need to dismantle). It's for everyone. Since being with other people is not under your control in the Stoic sense, desiring to not be alone is to desire something not under your control. Learning to abide change doesn't make you unchanging. The masculine is more analytical, a provider and protector, while the feminine is more creative, supportive and nurturer. This begs the question, is Stoicism a masculine trait? Stoicism is not inherently masculine or feminine. IDGAF what 'society celebrates' the stoic masculine man who can be roused to passionate aggression is still a lady killer. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Tall dudes can be either way but I've found that short guys who do well with girls are better if they are stoic. If it is outside your control, go have lunch. Stoicism could be seen as a way of taking on that emotional weight. Another characters that comes to mind brings a bit of a tonal shift, but this character also embodies many stoic traits in my opinion: Ichiban Kasuga from Yakuza: Like a Dragon. Often, traits such as strength, courage, and being self-sufficient come up, but it seems to me that they can all be just as easily applied to being a grown-up woman. 2. If we have the masculine ideal propping up stoicism, that raises the question of validity. Remember that you know yourself far better than anyone else ever can, and Stoic thought will show you that any term applied to you is only the opinion of the person making the appellation. Stoicism as a philosophy won’t necessarily make someone appear or come across as ‘cold’ or ‘emotionless’. Unless you’ve intentionally given up social connection for some higher purpose, like a monk, you should make an effort to have friends and intimate (not synonymous with sexual) relationships, which may include depending on others for certain things. I think toxic masculinity encourages little-s stoicism, and not big-s Stoicism as a philosophy. Using stoicism to review and observe your emotions from 10000 foot elevation gives you a layer of separation so the negative emotions don't effect you physically before you've had time time to decide Traditionally, masculinity is linked to physical strength and stoicism. Female character has a life of her own and is forced to be with the male character. It’s the image of the Roman emperor, Marcus Aurelius, or the stoic warrior enduring hardship. Stoicism is a masculine trait though. Mash Burnedead yep, One punch man was the first anime i watched, and its led me down this search for a good stoic main character. We're expected to be masculine and like that stuff. In fact, it teaches the opposite. I mean Zeno the founder of stoicism was incredibly rich before his ship sunk in which he’d later found stoicism, seneca was a very wealthy aristocrat (although I believe he was criticized for how he acquired his wealth but he’s still known as a prominent stoic figure), Aurelius while emperor quite literally had control of the vast majority Hell, some “alpha male” influencer accounts come across as really gay to me. Unemotionalness or Stoicism shouldn’t be a “masculine” trait, because venting and expressing emotions is healthy and a natural thing to do for any gender. For example, generic intelligence isn’t inherently masculine, but the mental capacity needed to overwhelm an opponent stra It makes sense that, given Stoicism emerged out of a white, male-dominated, European imperialist society that it would appeal as a source of misappropriation for fascist mythology. They have to prove mental fortitude/strength because people wouldn't expect that from a smaller I’ve been stoic before even knowing the meaning of stoicism, it can be a good and bad thing, the good is people can’t read you and won’t be able to play you, the bad is because people can’t read you it’s harder to make deeper connections. I think being a leader is an important masculine quality for instance. Little-s stoicism is attempting to be emotionless and rational. Jun 19, 2024 · Since the basic values are just as good and applicable for women? EDIT: More precise wording on this would've been "Why do you think interest Jan 21, 2024 · use the following search parameters to narrow your results: subreddit:subreddit find submissions in "subreddit" author:username find submissions by "username" site:example. I'm no stoic but I do feel that Spinoza is not giving them their due. Maybe it comes easier to male INFJs. Stoicism is about living a virtuous life, to live well and thrive. The Stoic Student Association’s mission is to educate the public on the lessons of Stoic philosophy and encourage the practical application of the teachings of philosophers from the Hellenistic to Roman Empires and beyond. In a modern context there is no reason why Stoicism should be more masculine than feminine however. No doubt. I have very deliberately avoided engaging in public discussions of stoicism because of the alt-right subset that does exist in online Stoic discussion (not the majority, but there is a very strong connection between stoicism, body building (male only) and the celebration of male strength. But for men it's different. It would be Think the four virtues of stoicism. Is the expectation of stoicism, the idea that men must be invulnerable, stable rocks a form of emotional labor? I could offer numerous examples from my own life, but don't want to be slapped down for making a purely personal post. Scan this QR code to download the app now. We want to know what it means to be a Stoic man. We're not allowed to break out of male stuff and like female stuff. I believe masculinity and femininity to be essential parts of every person. And I don’t feel the need to be. Be the first to comment Nobody's responded to this post yet. Stoicism doesn’t guarantee a life without suffering but an understanding that sometimes suffering is beyond your control. Ironically though, modern-day understanding of stoicism finds its origins in the ancient Greek philosophy Stoicism, focused on a set of ethics that prioritized mental tranquility and moral certainty above all. Let’s not worry about how others want us to be. It's an answer. I appreciate any honest feedback on my character and approach. My Stoic advice to young people is to learn about Stoicism. What you perceive as Stoicism in Peterson is mostly from some similarities between Christianity and Stoicism Tho I would be interested to hear him have a discussion with a real Stoic philosopher especially a traditional Stoic, that would be very interesting. if they don’t change their behavior walk away but you’re not going to allow people to treat you poorly and just put up with it because you’re a stoic One might argue that Stoicism has a masculine flavor--with its emphasis on practical effectiveness, mental resilience, and emotional self-regulation. Towards furthering awareness toward the true nature of oneself and reality. In this case, I'm using Jung to augment Stoic philosophy. For those of you who don’t know, stoicism is a a school of philosophy that teaches self-control, resilience and temperance. gym culture isn't far right, nor is being stoic. Now finally those people weren't trying to be mean to you, I guess its more about their acceptance and assent in ideas and wisdom of stoicism, and it seems (just an assumption) you don't have a much of relationship with stoicism and but just came here to see if it works and that's fine, Well i am sorry it doesn't work for you atleast in this case. Beard optional. The reason I’m saying stoicism is stupid is because it does promote emotional suppression, basically it indoctrinates you into having no emotions whatsoever, no empathy, no compassion, nothing. I see men desiring to be "masculine" as someone who is deeply insecure with themselves and their place in the world. You can have fun and enjoy life while being stoic in action. Stoicism teaches the development of self-control and fortitude as a means of overcoming destructive emotions. I don't think a stoic would minimize the existence of someone used to be dear to them to just a sex object that you had access to. Donald J. A lot of stoicism is about overcoming negative emotions to become a more virtuous person. But it generally also involves projecting strong (non-stoic) emotions The thing is from a Media perspectivi believe that a 100% stoic Character would be pretty boring to watch. It happens that the trait known as "stoicism", as used by people who don't know about the philosophy, is considered to be a masculine trait, and it is also a negative one. Explore your masculinity with our Stoic Coaches, and book a Free consultation here. Sorry to write such a combative post but some of the advice being given to people here looking for enlightened help is pissing me off, jerks wading in with hyper-masculine platitudes about 'manning up' and 'owning yourself' that have nothing whatever to do with actual Stoicism, and the most worrying thing is their vapid comments get likes into the triple figures. The word "Stoicism" is popular in our society today. It certainly does not openly disvalue alternative ideals, but, by virtue of promoting these above the rest, other ideals people might cherish are often out of focus. There’s nothing in real Stoicism that excludes women, aside from the same casual misogyny that is seen in pretty much all ancient works. Edit: Disclaimer: I don’t mean to portray stoicism so villainously. Ngl but sounds more like a guy that only cares about sex rather than a stoic. Its a spiritual journey toward personal growth and enlightenment. It's like this: Classical meant inspired by Greek literature. Certainly, it can involve repressing one's own negative emotions. It’s just not me. If you look back at pre-AA Long books like Gould’s Chrysippus he throws his hands up and gives up on the Compatiblism; it isn’t until Bobzien’s 1998 Determinism and Freedom that anything like a truly authoritative position exists. The primary character of Harry Turtledove's "Lost Legion" series (about a legion of Caesar's army that is transported from Gaul to another world, home to a Byzantine-styled empire) is a practicing Stoic, and was my first real introduction to the practicalities of Stoic thought. Is the heroic masculine purpose a real thing, and if so is there a place for it in Stoicism? Part of the draw of Stoicism for me is, the desire to live a virtuous life. You don't simply stumble upon this sub through happenstance and boredom and, frankly, claiming you're here for boredom is a backhanded insult that anyone else here with a functioning brain should see straight through. Stoicism and Masculinity . That is literally the opposite of Stoic virtue, I can’t for the life of me understand how you picked him. There's doubtless other stoic traits of his that I'm not able to recall, but he's the first fictional character that comes to mind. Stoicism lends itself to exploring this topic, but here we also need to make a distinction. It is happening all over reddit; quality subreddits with serious matter get overrun by kids that have seen 3 insta reels and are now experts, or certain influencers monetizing stoicism. Don't let the ironic mustache Brooklyn coffee shop hipsters fool ya. e. Stoicism is about the Selective Use of Will, not the abridgment of it. Facing adversity, doing things with purpose. I saw Vorenus as a stoic because he does his duty towards Rome as a citizen and legionnaire, no matter the horrific events which affect I know stoicism is about the mind regardless of sex, but since men and women are inherently different, are the teachings as helpful for women as they are men? If a woman applies stoicism in her life, does that take away some of her femininity since stoicism tends be geared toward more masculine principles? In essence, stoicism (as others have explained here), is a only to be applied from a personal viewpoint and we generally should not hold others to the standard that we try and hold ourselves to: no one rational (from the stoic definition) chooses to be vicious; it all comes from a lack of wisdom. It's been a while since I saw the series. Yes there is definitely this belief that stoicism is also just another example of toxic male behavior.