minimizeclose
minimizeminimize
minimizeclose

Sample response to reviewer comments. Our proposed manuscript revisions are underlined.

Sample response to reviewer comments Author’s response (agree with reviewer): We thank the reviewer for the comment. General Positive Review Response Example #2. ]} \vspace{20 pt} \noindent \textit{[A place for general comments regarding the comments and responses, plus a than-you to the reviewers. Reviewer comments Reviewer comments include answers to set questions, and then a list of general comments. We will be happy to address them, now in a timely manner. Instead, we’ve adjusted the colors and . 7 Negative Review Response Examples and Templates. If a change was made, indicate exactly where it was made in your manuscript so that we can easily find it. , ‘Name or code/nr of the paper: Detailed Response to the Editor and the Reviewers’) Intro text (see below) Reviewer #1 Reviewer's #1 comment 1 in blue letters Your response in black letters and so on Reviewer #2 Reviewer's #2 comment 1 in blue letters Your response 1 in black letters and so on May 7, 2019 · Frequently encountered deficiencies among authors’ responses to reviewers’ or editors’ comments include ignoring or incompletely addressing these comments, not being specific about where and what exactly was changed within the manuscript, not knowing how to address differing or contradicting suggestions of the reviewers, providing inadequate evidence as justification for not making Jul 3, 2024 · Teamflect’s digital performance review templates come with a built-in AI writing assistant that allows reviewers to enhance their review responses and comments with the help of AI! When responding to a performance review, you have the option: Lengthen ; Shorten ; Formalize ; Spell Check ; Regenerate Jun 13, 2023 · In some cases, reviewers may suggest ways in which the project could be improved that you may want to respond to. 2. Sep 20, 2024 · 3. You already have reviewers’ comments, for which you need to write responses and actions after making The revresponse environment is meant for responses to the individual comments of the reviewers and editor. Point-by-Point Response: Address each reviewer comment individually. Similar to the submission package for manuscript, when resubmitting a manuscript the resubmission package includes a response letter to the reviewers, which generally begins by thanking the reviewers for their commentary and includes a brief description of the major changes to the revised manuscript incurred by the feedback received; it Use the response column to delineate how you addressed the reviewer’s comment, preparing a response for each recommendation. Divide questions among the team and use track changes to ensure version control. Our proposed manuscript revisions are underlined. Once you’ve come down from the clouds, the right thing to do is to respond to the comments you’ve received in your review. Arranging the comments; Comments are sometimes are not in form of a list and are retained with the text. General Comments. PEOPLE AND PROJECTS BENEFIT FROM EFFECTIVELY WRITTEN COMMENTS AND RESPONSES . Based on Michael Underwood’s comments we added some details on the method and also added two citations (see response to comment further below). We will include an example from an actual comment made by a reviewer during a manuscript submission to a climate Oct 29, 2024 · This means that companies both large and small need to respond to online customer reviews. I usually put the reviewer comments in bold and then my answers underneath. The following is an example as to how to respond to a reviewer comment: Reviewer comment: “In your analysis of the data you have chosen to use a somewhat obscure fitting function (regression). We have included the data on XYZ and the ndings Aug 7, 2020 · 2) Using my DRM, I respond point-by-point to suggestions made by reviewers and editors. A generic one-sentence comment about language editing. Oct 1, 2024 · This example of a response to a journal editor’s decision letter demonstrates how to address the comments of peer reviewers on an submitted research paper Attached below are detailed responses to all the reviewer’s comments. Ensure that An online LaTeX editor that’s easy to use. Acknowledge and thank the reviewers for their efforts. We have incorporated all of the suggestions made by the reviewers. When responding to positive reviews, you want to express gratitude, reinforce the positive aspects praised by the customer, and encourage ongoing feedback and engagement. 2, 3. Recognize that they are subject experts in this process – just like you, so unless the editor indicates otherwise, make sure you address every concern raised. Add more rows to each table where needed. Do not ignore a reviewer’s comment. It is important to comment that most journal editors will tell you how they prefer this response. So, for the first part, you can just state that language editing for the revised paper has In particular, review response rates in Google search lift your SEO ranking, which leads to more eyeballs and higher customer conversion rates over time. It’s ok to Peer review is a process that helps you evaluate your work and that of others. Coauthors may be assigned a Jul 27, 2022 · All peer-review comments must be addressed, and the response must be suitably phrased. " Authors: We would like to thank epidemiologist Moro for his kind comments. ” is a terrific response, as is “Please see our response to comment 7 from reviewer 1. Comment 1: ‘Hidden Treasure: Scribal Hands in the Notorious Brigantine Manuscript’ was an engaging and informative read and the authors’ assessment of hands and scripts clear and accurate. Laboratory Testing Methodology (Sample description): Citation of methods is needed here. Want to take a shot at crafting your own responses, give our Review Response Generator a go to help build answers to negative, neutral, and positive reviews! Feb 5, 2019 · Title (e. Writing Your Response to Reviewer Comments. You’ll learn how to address feedback effectively and get that long-awaited “Manuscript Accepted” email. Review responses can make all the difference in how customers view a brand. Indicate line Nov 25, 2021 · The comments are very clear with no possibility of doubts. Your Response: Provide a clear, detailed response to the comment. If you think you will need additional time, please let us know and we will aim to respond within 48 hours. WCL2021-0376. For purposes of clarity, throughout my responses, 12/4/5 will mean page 12, paragraph 4, line 5 of the revised manuscript. The optional parameter changes the text on the first line. "The editors and reviewers don't have time to check the new draft line by line and find the author's changes. The reviewer is correct, and we have [explain the change made]. Your program officer may be able to advise you as Jan 17, 2023 · Do your best to respond in a professional manner publicly, but try to also address the situation privately or via a direct message so you can make sure your customer leaves with a somewhat positive emotion about your brand. Z . Here are seven negative review response templates: Response to Shipping Template for Latex and/or Pandoc to quickly write reviews and (author) response letters - mschroen/review_response_letter Advice is offered regarding the construction of a response document, outlining how editor and reviewer comments have been addressed in the revised manuscript and an example comprising both editor Reviewer’s comment: It would be interesting to include data on XYZ and conduct a multivariate analysis using these data. ] Response: [Type your response here. And it isn’t just negative reviews that require a response. Some may accept a DRM, others may want a letter, others may want a letter AND A REDLINED redlined = marked up with track changes) version, etc. Author’s Reply: The timeline for completing the Phase 3 of the study was 3 years The template has a few simple commands (myNotes and myTodo) that I like to use to leave colored text passages of in-progress items, but otherwise is a bare-bones template. Comment 2 Text Response: Response here. \arabic{point}} % command declarations for reviewer points and our responses Responding to reviewer critiques can be one of the most difficult steps in the publication process. Whether you’re celebrating achievements or addressing areas for improvement, these phrases will make your reviews more effective, leading to a more engaged and high-performing team. Be clear about how you responded (copy and paste the updated text below the reviewers’ comments) and state where this fits into the manuscript (with Response to reviewers template Instructions for authors Add each individual comment from reviewers and editors to the first column If you are responding to more than two reviewers, copy and paste one of the tables and edit the first column to read ‘Reviewer 3 Comment’, for example Feb 2, 2022 · Reply to Each Comment in Turn. See how to address different types of feedback, suggestions, and corrections from reviewers. Respond in-line to every comment, indicating line numbers where a change can be found. Examples of reviewer comments can help!Here you can find an overview of sample comments and examples for the most common review decisions: ‘minor revisions’, ‘major revisions’, ‘revise and resubmit’ and ‘reject’ decisions. p. There are too many comments and changes for us to list them all here. Our response follows (the reviewer’s comments are in italics). First, I want to thank you and your reviewers for the extremely helpful comments provided for our paper. It has taken us a rather long time to complete the final revision. Setting the Right Tone Part 1 Positive Phrases That Can Be Used in a Performance Review Part 2 How to Highlight an Employee’s Strengths with Specific Examples Part 3 Example Comments to Include to Provide Constructive Feedback Part 4 Structuring Your Comments Part 5 Using Examples in Comments Part 6 Encouraging Continuous Development Part 7 And there you have it – 25 solid responses you can use in a pinch for your positive reviews (just make sure to input customer names and info and you’re all set). different fonts or formatting for the comments and your replies, the response letter will be easier to read and evaluate. This can turn a dissatisfied customer into a loyal one. The latter are shown in blue and our responses in red. Apr 10, 2018 · I received the following reviewer comments which were a bit confusing and difficult to answer: 1. We love making our customer’s days and we can’t wait to have the opportunity to make you smile again! Thanks for choosing us! General Positive Review Response Example #3. A thorough response to the reviewers is only half the ticket. Aug 8, 2016 · From what I understand, the reviewer comments are in two parts: 1. ‘Song et al. No installation, real-time collaboration, version control, hundreds of LaTeX templates, and more. Comment 2 Text Response Example Format for Responses to Review Comments "This is my manuscript title" "Here are the author names" (It is important that you refer to line numbers in your response list. Our statistician made the following comments: E. Response: We have not added an additional chart as the requested data can already be found in Figure 1. Related: How To Conduct an Employee Evaluation Examples of performance evaluation comments May 3, 2020 · 2) Reviewer's comments: Typically, 2-3 reviewers. In this article, we provide 60 example phrases and 5 customizable response templates to help you May 17, 2024 · study and its results are clinically important. Respond point by point to the reviewers' comments and suggestions, stating how you dealt with all the criticisms in the summary statement. There are also some strong claims about the novelty of the study! We have previously discussed peer review generally (Why do the rules and conventions of academic publishing keep changing and how can researchers stay current?) and how authors can effectively respond to peer review (Writing effective response letters to reviewers: Tips and a template). Accept. Sufficient information about the previous study findings is presented for readers to follow the present study rationale and procedures. Reviewer 1. Mar 29, 2022 · Responses to Reviewers’ Comments for. Do not evade a reviewer’s comment. ” Jan 6, 2017 · Abstract: Presents sample review comments one might see. 35562). ]} The reviewer'€™s comments have RESPONSE: As was suggested, we corrected. In the process of publishing a peer-reviewed article, authors are often required to revise their original manuscript based on the comments from the reviewers. ” is a terrific response, as is “Please see our response to comment 7 from reviewer 1. Add each individual comment from reviewers and editors to the first column. Apr 13, 2016 · If you can use different fonts or formatting for the comments and your replies, the response letter will be easier to read and evaluate. This article will cover the other side: being a reviewer. Apr 13, 2022 · This article will (1) help you understand why it’s important to respond properly to such comments; (2) what exactly should be included in a response or rebuttal letter; and (3) how to respond appropriately to reviewers’ comments. We are grateful to the reviewer for taking time to carefully review the manuscript and give detailed and constructive comments, which has greatly helped to improve this paper. Although some of these comments are straightforward and concise, others are conflicting and unclear and, as such, authors may find it challenging to plan and carry out Abstract An author’s response to referees’ comments is a key component of the peer review process that affects whether a manuscript is accepted or rejected, the speed at which a manuscript moves through the review process, the workload of editors and referees, and the quality and clarity of published science. Here’s a clear format for this section: Restate the Reviewer’s Comment: Use bold or italic text to make the reviewer’s comment stand out. Sample Response Letters: Sample Response Letter 1: October 12, 2020 Subject: Responses to Initial Plan Check Comments Project Address: XXX Street Project Permit #: B20-014111 To Town of Danville Building Division, Please find below responses to the Initial Plan Review Comment Letter dated, XX,XX,2020 for the referenced project. . Appropriate English editing is necessary. Our app offers automated reminders and customized templates that fuel the review cycle. Jun 21, 2022 · The goal of every author is to have their research work published. It can be tempting to respond with spite about specific reviewer comments. You can explain these typographical conventions in the introduction to your response. Specific Comments from Reviewer 1 Reviewer Comments Reply Abstract: Please focus the abstract on 'Minor revisions’ means that a manuscript only has to undergo small changes and improvements before it can be published in an academic journal. Your reviews are most helpful. As noted by the Reviewer, the authors feel that the length restraint of a Brief Communication prohibits the inclusion of a Supplementary Information section. Learn how to write a point-by-point response to reviewers' comments on your manuscript, with examples and explanations. Best Practices for Handling Negative Feedback The Do’s and Don’ts of Review Response Peer-reviewing an academic manuscript is not an easy task. A good response letter can mean the difference between acceptance and rejection, and so it is important to get it right. Nature, for instance, began to trial publishing peer reviews Therefore, I invite you to respond to the reviewer(s)' comments and revise your manuscript. Here are 20 examples and samples of how you can respond to a good performance review: How to Respond to a Good Performance Review Samples “Thank you for the positive review. The Response to reviewers template Instructions for authors Add each individual comment from reviewers and editors to the first column If you are responding to more than two reviewers, copy and paste one of the tables and edit the first column to read ‘Reviewer 3 Comment’, for example Oct 12, 2017 · Rule 6: Use typography to help the reviewer navigate your response. This entails summarising the key adjustments you have made to the revised article, emphasizing the key ideas, and describing how the modifications answer the reviewers’ feedback. Responses to Positive Feedback "Thank you for recognizing my efforts. Use changes of typeface, color, and indenting to discriminate between 3 different elements: the review itself, your responses to the review, and changes that you have made to the manuscript. Resist the trap of lazy responses like “answered” or “fixed in manuscript”. Please see below, in blue, our detailed response to comments. As much as possible, this memo includes the exact changes made to the manuscript. 5 Project Evaluation (10) 8 8 8 Total 92 94 93 Competitive Priority Points 0 0 0 Total Score 92 94 93 Compiled Reviewer Comments by Criteria. I am To prevent a delay in your response, answer the comment as you have interpreted it and ask the reviewer to confirm that your response actually addresses their comment. In the response, reviewers comments related to all criteria may be addressed, for example, if a reviewer has questioned the research areas the proposal addresses this can be discussed in the response. " Dec 5, 2024 · If you need positive reviews response examples in a pinch, you’ll definitely find some below, as I have covered over 35 different positive review response templates: General positive review examples. However, we would like to highlight some of the more general ones. Comment 1 [Paste the full comment here and italicize it. I do have some comments regarding some of the wording used by the authors in the introduction Reviewer: In lines 20-25 under “With few exceptions (e. Jun 28, 2016 · Response to Reviewer 3. 1 The next immediate step after peer review, if the authors are lucky enough, is to revise the manuscript according to editors’ and reviewers’ comments. Reviewer comment: Please consider providing information to help readers interpret table 2A. RESPONSE: The text was corrected by a native English speaker. This is no place for philosophy or speculation. If Reviewer Comments to Author(s): Reviewer #1 (Jillon Vander Wal, PhD): Overall, this is a clear, concise, and well-written manuscript. Jan 26, 2023 · It’s crucial to be succinct and clear when outlining your response to the reviewers’ comments in the cover letter. Wr i t i n g a re sp o n se to t h e rev i ewe rs’ co m m e nt s Th e re sp on se to t h e rev i ewe rs’ com m e nt s i s on e of t h e m ost i m p or tant p ar t s of you r rev i se d m an u Oct 30, 2024 · In this guide, we’ve compiled 120 Performance Review Example Phrases & Comments for 2024 to help you provide meaningful feedback. Here is a point-by-point response to the reviewers’ comments and concerns. In such a case, the comments should be shorted down and incorporated in a tabular format. spent three years to sample and investigate the respond to each reviewer in turn. Effectively written comments and responses: Improve the quality of planning products, decision making, and project implementation, Save time and funding, Possible Reviewer #1 Reviewer #2 Score Project Design (25) 22 23 22. Providing thoughtful performance review comments can show your employees you are invested in their growth and development. While the bulk of the work will consist in addressing critical points, don’t forget to include positive points raised by the reviewers to retain the full picture of their assessment of your manuscript. Some reviewers are adjudicative reviewers who assess your manuscript as well as comments from other reviewers. Reviewers' Comments to the Authors: Reviewer 1 . Highlight the changes. Comments from Reviewer 1 [How to respond to comments that you agree with] Comment 1: [Paste the full comment here and italicize it. Your review made our day Feb 12, 2015 · "The main mistake I see in authors' responses to reviewers' comments is in what I call the 'ergonomy' of the information – how well it's described to the editors and reviewers," says Professor Pázsit. Respond to Review Comments . Also, I have provided my responses to each comment in italics below the original reviewer comment. Especially if you are unsure about how to formulate your feedback. Aug 29, 2010 · Excellent question. COMMENTS Jul 16, 2024 · Questions about Response To Reviewers Comments 1. Apr 3, 2019 · Organize your responses by listing each of the reviewers’ comments and addressing each one separately below. If the peer-review comments require additional references to be added, include them; reviewers occasionally make suggestions for references that are more recent, pertinent, or helpful to the overall research. Please let us know if you still have any questions or concerns about the manuscript. ] Download Table | Suggested template for providing response to reviewers' comments from publication: Satisfying Doubters and Critics: Dealing with the Peer Review | Although peer review process Keep your responses clear, unemotional, and easy to follow. Use this as a template to guide your own response to reviewers, being sure to modify the content to address the specific comments raised by reviewers of your manuscript. Reviewers' comments: Reviewer's Responses to Questions Comments to the Author 1. Check again that your Specific Aims line up with your hypothesis. All page numbers refers to the manuscript file with tracked changes. It’s true that 97% of consumers that read reviews also read a brand’s responses. % define counters for reviewers and their points \newcounter{reviewer} \setcounter{reviewer}{0} \newcounter{point}[reviewer] \setcounter{point}{0} % This refines the format of how the reviewer/point reference will appear. If you review a manuscript and struggle to formulate your feedback to reflect a 'minor revisions' verdict, look no further: get inspired by explanations, sample comments and examples! Contents When to decide Respond to ALL queries and ALL author instructions • Provide thorough responses—do not leave any stone unturned • Make it EASY for the reviewer and editor to understand your response • If you do not understand a review comment, it is okay to admit it. ] Thank you for pointing this out. ". A simple “Done. \renewcommand{\thepoint}{P\,\thereviewer. We have carefully reviewed the comments and thoroughly revised the manuscript accordingly. Reviewer Comment 1: Suggestion for additional charts. We are enclosing our clarifications (answers in line) to the reviewer questions below with pointers to actual revisions in the manuscript in bold text in response to the reviewer’s comments. 1) Authors include GEOS-Chem and conclude that GEOS-Chem‟s performance is less satisfied Feb 12, 2015 · "The main mistake I see in authors' responses to reviewers' comments is in what I call the 'ergonomy' of the information – how well it's described to the editors and reviewers," says Professor Pázsit. Dec 2, 2024 · In this guide, we’ll break down how to respond to reviewer comments with confidence and professionalism. made in a copy of your revised manuscript improve the work and address their concerns as per the specific comments below. Your strategy can be a game changer here: a thoughtful, clear and effective response to the reviewers can not only speed up the publication process but it also gives you a chance to improve your work, to show professionalism, and eventually to gain advocates to your work. By default, this text is "Thank you for the comment. Some tips on drafting your Dec 18, 2023 · Be selective; you don’t have to respond to every comment; 60+ Feedback Response Templates. However, our tailored function allows for the analysis of the data in terms of the Smith model [Smith et al, 1998]. 3. 2 This is an important step as May 1, 2024 · Additionally, employees should also be able to aptly respond to these praises and criticisms. 5 Adequacy of Resources (20) 20 20 20 Management Plan (25) 25 25 25 Project Services (20) 17 18 17. increased risk of preterm birth[24] and non- Oct 1, 2024 · Reviewer Comments, Author Responses and Manuscript Changes. We have studied comments carefully and have made correction in line with the suggestions made by you. In the paper we’ve addressed all comments – both specific and general – from all three reviewers. Edward Researcher Palaeography Institute 1717 Writer’s Lane South River, MI, USA, 484848 734-734-7344 [email protected] Dr Helen Wordsmith Assistant Editor Journal of the Shipping Manuscripts Society 717 Reader’s Row London, UK, SW6 9DE [email protected] November 14, 2017 Thank you for the very thorough review and thoughtful comments on our manuscript. The following are general examples of ways an employee could respond to his or her manager after hearing some of the previous phrases. CRITERIA 1: Quality of Project Design. This is no place for philosophy or specula-tion. This is to ensure the quality, originality and accuracy of the work submitted to the journals. Positive reviews also deserve the attention of company managers and customer service representatives. Revised portion are marked in blue in the paper. " Response letter Dear Reviewers, Thank you for your comments. Response to Reviewers’ Comments This document contains copies of all comments of the reviewers (in italicized, blue text) and our planned effort to address them (in normal, black text). However, guidance on how to write a response to manuscript reviews is lacking COMMENT RESPONSE DISCUSSION* BACKCHECK . Nov 14, 2018 · Since there were no previous studies to refer to, we conducted a study under the name "Pilot study" and contributed to the protocol paper. On behalf of my co-authors, we very much appreciate the time and effort you have put into your comments on our manuscript (NO. Feb 5, 2019 · Be precise and respond to every single comment. +129 negative and positive google review response examples: Good review response templates on Google business profile ‍ Catering sector review response example on Google: ‍ Review: "I absolutely loved your restaurant! The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Intelligent Trajectory Planning in U A V-mounted Wireless Networks: A Quantum-Inspired Reinforcement Learning Perspective. When you write your response to reviewer comments, you then have the option to make the changes that the reviewers recommend or not. Responding to these reviews not only shows appreciation but also strengthens relationships with your customers. It can be a valuable tool in ensuring the quality and credibility of any project or piece of research. Keep your responses short, direct, and to the point. Improve retention and employee satisfaction with WorkDove’s review capabilities. To support the continuity of the peer review process, we recommend returning your manuscript to us within 21 days. Response to Reviewer 2 Comment 1 Text Response: Response here to include any required evidence such as tables, figures, additional results, etc. And there you have it – 25 solid responses you can use in a pinch for your negative reviews (just make sure to input customer names and info and you’re all set). The main corrections in the paper and the responds to the reviewer’s comments and remarks are as flowing. There are a range of reviewer comments, such as: review correspondence associated with published papers (reviewer comments, author responses, editor decision letters), with the permission of reviewers and authors. Your positive review response also shows how you treat your customers. The introduction is relevant and theory based. You don’t have to respond to every single comment, especially if they are of the ‘typo on page 15’ type. Is the manuscript technically sound, and do the data support the conclusions? The manuscript must describe a technically sound piece of scientific research with data that supports the conclusions. Below is our point-by-point response to each respective comment. ” Therefore, I invite you to respond to the reviewer(s)' comments and revise your manuscript. Response to reviewer comments Paper Number: 07C27 Author(s): Hao Zhang Oliver van Kaick Ramsay Dyer Paper Title: Spectral mesh processing Dear Editor and reviewers: We greatly appreciate the thorough and thoughtful comments provided on our submitted article. In this contribution, I present and describe the content of the response document in the format of a specimen by discussing different situations that may be encountered when dealing with This is a sample response to reviewers. It’s important to show respect to the reviewers as their comments could improve your work in ways you might not appreciate at first. And do not say ‘this is addressed in the paper’, without really having addressed it (if you are not 100% sure that you addressed it, then you haven’t). Sometimes there will also be a tracked changes version of your manuscript along with comments imbedded in the document. Nov 11, 2014 · The revised manuscript is then submitted to the journal along with a point-by-point response to the reviewer comments. 4. Jul 13, 2020 · For responding to peer review comments, you may find the following resources helpful: How to respond to comments by peer reviewers; How can I reply to peer review comments requesting additional experiments? How to handle peer review comments [Course] All the best for the next steps! Mar 11, 2019 · When you get your email back, if the editor has presented you with the opportunity to revise the manuscript, you then need to write a response to reviewer comments. By coincidence, last week I received a response to referees where the contents of my report were rather mangled. Copy templates to use them anywhere: 30 Positive Review Response Templates (No Comments) Even if your customers don’t leave written feedback, it’s still important to respond appropriately and show people that you value their business. Sep 11, 2021 · A Sample Response to the Comments of Peer Reviewers. Continuous improvement based on customer feedback can boost your business and enhance customer satisfaction. Engaging in peer review lets you take a fresh look at something you may have become familiar with. I finally got the answer after a very long review period, but fortunately I was asked to do a minor revision I would like to ask about the ambiguity. Comment 2 [Paste the full comment here and italicize it. Reviewer 1 Overall I was not impressed by the methodological advancements or the scientific implications of this Reach out to the reviewers, apologize for their negative experiences, and offer solutions. 1. Capitalize on your strengths and throw out or revise the parts reviewers felt were weak. Response to Reviewer 1 Comment 1 Text Response: Response here to include any required evidence. This detail is now added to the description of sample preparation. How to Effectively Write and . Be polite. After your general letter, copy each reviewer comment into the document and reply to it specifically. The paper is perfect for the Journal of the Shipping Manuscripts Society. How do I respond to reviewers’ comments effectively? To respond to reviewers’ comments effectively, follow these steps: read the comments carefully, identify the main points, prepare a response that addresses each point, be polite and professional, and submit your response promptly. ] Author response: Thank you for pointing this out. Return the revised manuscript and response letter within the time period allotted by the editor. Before addressing the comments, it may be helpful to categorize the feedback into different themes, such as methodologic issues, data analysis, clarity of writing, and references. Sep 13, 2019 · The reviewers and editors believe in your paper. If you are responding to more than two reviewers, copy and paste one of the tables and edit the first column to read ‘Reviewer 3 Comment’, for example. Kind regards, Yuan-Pang Wang Editorial Board Member BMC Public Health Reviewer Comments: Reviewer 1 When resubmitting your manuscript, you will be asked to write a response letter that addresses a collection of comments and questions from the reviewers. \end{generalcomment} \begin{revresponse}[We appreciate your handling of the review process. I/We agree with this comment. When working with co-authors, send everyone the reviews immediately. COMMENT: Please reproduce the review comment. How you write your response letter will depend on how the reviewer comments were written. It includes suggested language for responding to comments from reviewers. Use a table to systematically respond to review comments and explain any Feb 25, 2022 · The response letter encompasses the reviewer’s comments, author’s response, and actions. Want to take a shot at crafting your own responses, give our Review Response Generator a go to help build answers to positive, neutral, and negative reviews! Peer review is the indispensable part of publishing a scientific paper, in particulars in high-impact journals. We Often the lead author writes the entire revision and author response letter, but comments and sections may also be divided among the group, to distribute the workload. ] According to the reviewers' comments, we have checked our manuscript and addressed them in the following way: \begin{enumerate} \item We added content. The changes resulting in the paper due to the reviewer comments are in our manuscript. The tables should have details of comments and also the response that is been given. Apr 8, 2024 · As a manager, you can use these comments to offer clear examples of the successes and challenges of an employee. Aug 7, 2020 · 2) Using my DRM, I respond point-by-point to suggestions made by reviewers and editors. @Andrew: Including cut-out chunks of pdf from the original might work out to be the best strategy. These responses are great for customer reviews that include general praise about your business without going into specifics: May 30, 2019 · Responding to reviewer comments effectively will help to make this stage an edifying rather than painful experience. WorkDove provides an easy-to-use performance review tool that integrates employee goals, recognition, 360-feedback, and Workplace Satisfaction results. 1. Published in: 2017 11th International Conference on Intelligent Systems and Control (ISCO) Article #: Response disagreeing with the reviewer: “We agree with the reviewer that a simple Gaussian fit would facilitate comparison with the results of other studies. To facilitate planning, the lead author can create a comment and response table (see Table 1), which includes every editor and reviewer comment. Hi [CUSTOMER NAME], Your kind words about our [PRODUCT/SERVICE NAME] are really appreciated. We agree that the reviewer’s sug-gestion will enhance further understanding on our ndings. The treatment could have been altered to suit the research question better specially with regard to the experimental group. In my opinion, a simple Gaussian function would have Tips for revisions and responding to review comments. COMMENT: There are some grammatical errors in the text. A cover letter for a revised manuscript should be sent to the editor along with the author’s responses to the reviewer comments. Reviewers' comments 1 : "Sample size: The stated sample size of 50 is larger than what would be Response to Reviewer #3: We would like to thank the reviewer for careful and thorough reading of this manuscript and for the thoughtful comments and constructive suggestions, which help to improve the quality of this manuscript. A list of editorial formatting comments. RESPONSE: Please state your response. This letter is often called the response letter or the rebuttal letter. g. RESPONSE TO REVIEWER’S COMMENTS Section: research methodology Query 1: Were all the par cipants examined within a short period of me? The me dura on of data collec on would have been informa ve. ljlam pmc ncmk dkojwk jexned kqpamxc qowkqd uss eswbj kaenoo ezarwow csfy vcqloss fhxw lzy