Awaiting reviewer selection desk reject meaning. It depends on whether the editor invites new reviewers.

Awaiting reviewer selection desk reject meaning " Should I expect a desk rejection? Peer Review in Progress. What does it mean? rejected right? Probably the AE has received the paper and is now about to read it. If all the reviewers accept the invitations, the peer review process will start and the status will change to "Under review. Mar 13, 2020 · Does the status "Awaiting final decision" within a week of submission indicate desk rejection? What does a status change from "Awaiting reviewer score" back to "Awaiting reviewer assignment" mean? Answered by Editage Insights on 16 Mar, 2020 Sep 15, 2020 · As you already seem to know, the Awaiting Decision status means that the AE has made a decision on the manuscript and referred this decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EIC) for the final decision. Aug 8, 2020 · ‘Awaiting Reviewer’ means that the manuscript has been sent to the peer reviewers. Related reading: What does a status change from "Awaiting reviewer score" back to "Awaiting reviewer assignment" mean? May 27, 2020 · I received a mail about five hours after submission stating: It is a pleasure to inform you that your manuscript titled XYZ has passed initial screening and is now awaiting reviewer selection. Feb 27, 2021 · Awaiting Reviewer Scores means that your paper is being peer reviewed. the status of “awaiting reviewer assignment” just last for less than one day, and on the same day, the status was changed to “awaiting reviewer scores”. The status will change to "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" then probably go through a couple more cycles of "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment. However, yesterday the status reverted back to "Awaiting Reviewer Selection". Aug 9, 2022 · I submitted a paper to a journal of Emerald Publishing. After 40 days of the status being Awaiting Reviewer Selection, it changed to Awaiting EIC Decision. ” Why has nothing been done with it? In some cases, ScholarOne will show that status even if a manuscript is under review. Jul 18, 2019 · I have made a major revision after receiving one very positive feedback and one very negative feedback for my manuscript. At my journal we ask our AE's to make the initial decision (select reviewers or decline without review) within a week of being assigned a paper, but it often takes longer. ' Does this signify that my manuscript has got desk-rejected? I submitted my manuscript 3 months back. Up to now, 11 weeks passed but the status is still AWAITING REFEREE SELECTION. Aug 5, 2014 · UgkR4R‡ ÀÕ=$¢²×ÃN °9iõ¨Z$d^°úãן þûO Á¸û ´lÇåöx}~_¾ÍúïäçËÑ« {ñ…¹ Œg^BÈÍ È1¤R²Ý6 Yr$ ›0üo~³ÿ “ÑŽéÆU »J’ý May 3, 2019 · I submitted a manuscript to Springer Journal. However, I just noticed that the status of my revised manuscript Sep 20, 2017 · What does it mean that the status of a submitted major revision is simultaneously 'awaiting reviewer scores' and 'awaiting decision'? 2 How to handle situation in which the article has been "Awaiting reviewer assignment" for 5 months? Aug 4, 2021 · What is the meaning of "Awaiting Referee Scores" after revision ? the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span Oct 9, 2018 · Generally speaking, the status "Awaiting a reviewer reply" could mean either of two things: 1. I have previously published in the same journal and it had taken 5 months to complete the first round. Once initial check up is done on your manuscript, the EIC will screen your manuscript to check if it fits the scope of the journal and if it is of sufficient interest to the journal's readership. Your manuscript has cleared desk screening and is being sent for peer review – that’s one step/obstacle crossed. Do I just keep waiting, send another email? What should I do with this frustrating Sep 11, 2017 · I submitted my revised manuscript to a mathematical journal since 12-04-2017. The status of the paper changed several times. . Then I revised and resubmitted. Some editorial systems give the Mar 28, 2015 · Perhaps on that particular editorial management system, this means that the AE is in the process of deciding whether to desk reject the paper or to send it to review. In case it’s a revise-and-resubmit decision, you may prepare yourself by going through these resources: Jun 24, 2023 · “Awaiting Referee Scores” is a stage in the publication process where enough experts have agreed to read and evaluate a manuscript. The following query and answer may be of further help to you: In contrast, if in this journal the peer-review typically takes several months, then it might be long desk-rejection. After incorporating the comments of reviewers, I resubmitted the paper. In this case, the reviewers were already lined up to get the revision, and so it doesn't make sense for "awaiting reviewer scores" to just mean that the reviewing is in progress -- in fact, it's "under review" that means that, and it doesn't make sense for "under review" to mean pre-screening. Aug 16, 2024 · Here's what each status likely means: Awaiting Reviewer Selection: The editor is trying to find suitable reviewers for your revised manuscript. ’ What this means is that your manuscript has been sent for peer review and the peer review comments/opinions are presently awaited. Oct 14, 2023 · I recently had a paper desk-rejected (i. To edit the paper status, click on the edit icon. These status should not be taken seriously. Sep 18, 2020 · For instance, if ‘Awaiting Final Decision’ happened earlier, it may mean the AE first decided to refer their decision to the EIC, but changed their mind, and then decided to send it for review. Your article has secured the minimum number of required reviewers. Jul 16, 2019 · Anyone give me some advice: I have made a major revision after receiving one very positive feedback and one very negative feedback for my manuscript. After one day of submission, status was ‘Awaiting Decision’; but now after 10 days, status change into ‘Awaiting reviewer selection’. The handling editor considers all the returned reviews before making a 2 days ago · Peer review is an integral part of the publishing process, learn more about the peer review process, including: what the reviewer is looking for, the possible outcomes of peer review, common reasons for rejection, what to do if your manuscript is rejected, and how to respond to the reviewer comments. I am not A delay does not mean that it will be a bad review, and AEs are often not great with the system and leave "awaiting assignment" even if some reviews already came in. Another possibility in such a situation would be that the manuscript is being accepted as is, which is extremely rare. The paper stayed in the "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" stage for around three months. Dec 7, 2021 · Thank you for your question. Unfortunately, a direct “decision in process” or “awaiting final decision” without undergoing peer review possibly means that the manuscript will be desk rejected. After a few days, the status changed to "under peer review". Awaiting EIC decision must have appeared after the first status while you did not check your status! It Appearing after short interval of awaiting reviewer assignment clearly means that associate editors have advised against it! Now the EIC has to make decision. Oct 17, 2024 · If the manuscript does not match the journal's scope or does not meet the journal's standards, it may be returned without review or be desk rejected. If the ‘Reviewer Invited’ status preceded, it means that at least one reviewer has agreed to review the paper. After that, it changed to Awaiting Referee Selection once again. Under review: The paper is now under review. Desk reject after "awaiting reviewer selections" status. In case ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ happened earlier, they initially decided to send it for review, but changed their mind, and decided to Aug 21, 2021 · If this status is updated soon after submission, it could mean a desk rejection. The status is remained “Awaiting Reviewer Selection” since then. Submission status 'Awaiting Reviewer Selection' Economist aacc. So, good job there! :) As you can see, nothing much is needed from your side for Peer Review in Progress. Building an effective reviewer database. 5. Eic usually signifies the Editor in chief. What does this mean? Will it go for review? Mar 5, 2019 · In short, the switching of the status repeatedly from “awaiting reviewer selection” to “awaiting reviewer assignment” and back implies that the editor is having a hard time finding reviewers for your paper. Interestingly, it is/was awaiting "reviewer" (not reviewers- in a plural form) recommendations. Finally, the last status is the one most relevant to you. Does this indicate rejection? Meaning of Awaiting EIC Decision for over 20 days Dec 28, 2024 · 投的chinese journal of catalysis 目前状态是Awaiting Reviewer Selection，会被编辑直接拒搞吗 首页 论文范文 毕业论文 论文发表 论文格式 期刊 论文大全 期刊问答 问答百科 期刊大全 最新期刊 论文问答 杂志问答 Jul 1, 2020 · In case it’s a desk rejection, as you know, you can make any changes as necessary and submit to another journal. Aug 19, 2021 · Awaiting Reviewer Selection: This is ideally the first stage of the peer review process where the assigned Editor will select some suitable experts to invite to review your manuscript. The status of my paper changed to"Editor assignment pending". I submitted a paper at Management Science recently, and It only took 3 days for the status to change from "under review" to "Awaiting AE Recommendation". Now the status is awaiting DE decision. As the statuses have changed so quickly, the decision might be quick too. A review invitation has been sent out but the reviewer has not yet accepted it. My recent view has been, unless there is a big time push such as my student needing to graduate or a grant that has to go out, to wait it out possible delays for good journals. Mar 9, 2022 · Answer: Dear author, The editorial hierarchy varies from journal to journal. As you've mentioned, you have addressed the previous reviewer's concerns, so the EIC may suggest moving the manuscript to peer-review based on what you have addressed. May 1, 2021 · I submitted a manuscript to a journal by SAGE. As of today, it says "Awaiting Recommendation". I submitted a manuscript that went through the entire peer review process. A good compromise between precision and conciseness would arguably awaiting potential reviewer selection or awaiting editorial assessment, but there are also journals who call this just awaiting reviewer selection. This decision may normally take up to 2 weeks. Dec 2, 2021 · About two months after my article was submitted, its status changed from "awaiting reviewer selection" to "awaiting PE decision". Jul 31, 2021 · As for your question about the “awaiting reviewer selection” status, please note that this status indicates that the journal editor is looking for peer reviewers for your paper, which means that your manuscript has cleared desk screening (congratulations!). " It's a s**t show. The paper has been assigned the minimum amount of reviewers Review and selection of manuscripts. Once the review invitations are sent, the status changes to "Reviewers invited. Decision notification e-mails and what they mean There are several decisions that authors may receive after submitting their paper to one of the Society’s journals: Reject without review: The Action Editor has rejected the paper without sending it for peer review. Peer reviewers are given 2 weeks to submit their review of your article. Even when the editor was not assigned, the term 'under review' was used. to revise, accept or reject the paper). Does this mean the article is rejected? Meaning of the "Awaiting PE Decision" in journal status My paper status changed from "awaiting reviewer scores" to "under review" and then back to "awaiting reviewer scores. Whether the letter gets rejected will entirely depend on how well you fixed raised issues. Jun 15, 2020 · Meaning of ‘Awaiting reviewer scores’ This status is known by different names with different journals, including ‘Under review’ and ‘Awaiting technical scores. 8. This may, however, vary across journals. “Awaiting Reviewer Selection. ' Does this signify that my manuscript has got desk-rejected? What does "awaiting reviewer selection" really mean under the "minor revision" scenario? 1. (The journal I submitted to allows it to be reprinted by Nov 5, 2019 · The status "Reviewers contacted" means that the editor has sent out review invitations to the requisite number of reviewers (usually 2 or 3). Then I revised and resubmitted the paper. This decision is typically made if the manuscript is deemed unsuitable for the journal, either due to its content or failure to meet specific submission criteria. The review is then submitted to the journal, with the reviewer’s recommendation (e. If the paper is not rejected, there are three possible recommendations: “accept (as is)”, “minor revision”, and “major revision”. I suppose that in most cases of minor revision, the revised manuscript will only be reviewed by the ADM or associate editor. This stage is used less frequently. The outcome of the review process might be difficult to anticipate based on the status of the article, as the particular meaning of this status varies from journal to journal. While such a quick change suggests that it may be a desk rejection, there may be some reason to hope. Does it mean the paper has been sent for peer review or is it still eligible for desk rejection? Please advise. The status is "Waiting for reviewer assignment" since 24-4-2017. In which case, to avoid or minimize the chances of a desk rejection, you may send the other journal(s) a presubmission inquiry. It is almost 5 months since resubmission. However, if the status is “Awaiting reader selection,” it would mean something completely different. May 8, 2024 · Desk rejection occurs when the editor of a journal decides not to send a submitted manuscript out for peer review. All submissions will first be subject to an in-house evaluation process with respect to suitability for BLC in terms of quality, content and methodology. For instance, it’s not clear if the initial status was ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ or whether there was some other status prior to that. After a short time, the status of the manuscript changed to ‘Reviewer selection,’ then ‘Reviewer assignment’, then ‘Reviewer selection’, and then ‘Reviewer assignment’ again. 6. This change has occurred Nov 26, 2021 · I submitted a manuscript and the status changed from Awaiting AE assignment to Awaiting Referee Selection and then Awaiting Referee Assignment. It is totally confusing. Desk (or Bench) Reject Policy. None of them has agreed to take on the assignment yet. May 6, 2021 · Does it mean your paper will go through another round of review? Not necessarily. Jul 15, 2019 · A manuscript is sent for peer review only after it has cleared the admin check and the initial screening. A manuscript typically gets a desk review by the Editor-in-Chief. If the two reviews are insubstantial, highly conflicting or raise any cause for concern, a further review should be sought. Try to address the comments, and try again. But, while the RE is deciding, the software I'm familiar with defaults to "Assigning reviewers". Maybe. Jul 24, 2018 · However, in your case, since the paper was not assigned to an Associate Editor, I feel inclined to think that the "Under Review" status refers to the initial editorial review, not peer review. Although I understand this isn’t a long period of time in the grand scheme, for the past two months the paper’s status has cyclically changed from “awaiting reviewer assignment” to “awaiting reviewer selection”. How to calculate standard deviation when only mean of the data, sample size, and t-test is available? Jun 19, 2020 · This may mean a rejection or it may mean a requirement to revise and resubmit. As these examples illustrate, specific comments on the work are the key component of each review, not the reviewer’s recommendation per se. Oct 12, 2020 · The second update, Awaiting Referee Selection, means that the manuscript has completed the internal check and is now awaiting peer review. The reviewer has accepted the invitation and the editor is waiting to receive reviewer comments. If it passes it may be assigned to a subject matter expert Review Editor, who does another desk review. Dec 29, 2024 · 投了一个半月了，状态一直在awaiting reviewer selection 和 awaiting reviewer assignment之间变化，来回 首页 论文范文 毕业论文 论文发表 论文格式 期刊 论文大全 期刊问答 问答百科 期刊大全 最新期刊 论文问答 杂志问答 In the case that you accidentally reject the “transfer to Sage Path” offer, please reach out to the journal that initially rejected your manuscript and ask them to send you a new Sage Path transfer link. The first status read "Awaiting Admin Processing", then 2 days later it read "Pre-Review Stage". Sep 28, 2020 · The ‘Assigning Reviewers’ status here and the quick change from it probably refers to the internal review rather than the external (peer) review. However, I definitely remember the last two: from "awaiting reviewer recommendations" to "awaiting final decision". ’) So, great, that’s one step cleared in the submission/publication process! Aug 30, 2020 · Answer: The status ‘Awaiting Referee Selection’ typically means that the manuscript is awaiting peer review. You may learn more through this similar related query: What does the journal status "Awaiting reviewer reply" mean? Jan 10, 2022 · Dear author, we’re sorry that you are in this unfortunate and frustrating position. This means that while the manuscript cleared the desk screening and was deemed good to go for peer review, the journal is finding it somewhat challenging to identify the right peer reviewers for your paper. Nov 13, 2016 · As far as I know, the "Awaiting EIC Decision" status is the final time when the chief editor to decide whether to accept or reject the paper, but it seems the editors handled with my manuscript a little slow. He will then decide if it should be send to refs or rejected. If the RE thinks it is worthy, they assign reviewers. After some days, the status of the paper was changed from Submitted to Journal to AWAITING REFEREE SELECTION. Since it has been about a month since the status “Awaiting a reviewer Mar 15, 2016 · A rejected paper is sometimes resubmitted to the same journal, after some revisions. After several weeks I received an email saying that"Based on the advice received, the Editor feels that your manuscript could be accepted for publication should you be prepared to incorporate minor revisions". Apr 21, 2018 · The answer is that we can’t know. Dec 7, 2018 · I submitted a paper of mine to an Emerald journal. , reviewers think your letter has merit but needs major changes. Awaiting Editor Decision May 30, 2020 · Coming to your present query, as we just indicated, this has been a slow change from ‘Awaiting Reviewer Assignment’ to ‘Under Review. Jul 4, 2020 · I submitted my manuscript five weeks ago, and in a week, the status appeared as 'Awaiting Reviewer Selection. The status of the manuscript is exactly what it says on the tin - that it’s awaiting the decision of the EIC. Jul 1, 2017 · After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. g. You may want to request an update to expedite the rejection. " Related reading: Why does my manuscript's status keep changing from "awaiting reviewer selection" to "awaiting reviewer assignment"? Feb 6, 2021 · The EiC indicator is simpler: it tells you who the Editor-in-Chief is. But all of a sudden, instead of moving to "Under Review Nov 2, 2018 · Are you sure the status is “Awaiting reader selection” and not “Awaiting reviewer selection”? If it’s the latter, you can rest assured that your paper has cleared the initial editorial screening. Withdrawal of submitted manuscripts is not very common, and is not considered a best practice, so we would recommend that you try and contact the journal more directly if possible – through a direct contact number or by reaching out to different editors that work on the editorial board. " It was only submitted about 10 days ago. Mar 13, 2022 · I submitted an article in a scientific journal, after verification by the editor the status is changed (Awaiting Reviewer Scores), then after a month and a half, the status is changed again Nov 1, 2019 · The editors are reading it and checking their reviewer list. A desk reject response in 2022 was sent on average within 13 days. Yes, the chances of rejection have definitely increased in the bag held back by the editor. The ‘Accept’ perhaps means that it is awaiting the peer reviewers’ acceptance – that is, their readiness to review the manuscript. Perhaps, if this continues for some time without changing, you may want to consider writing to the journal editor seeking clarity. Last week I sent a gentle reminder to the editor and got no response. I think the first status update 'AE not assigned, under review' was used to refer to the initial admin check that is done by editorial assistants before the paper is sent for . May 12, 2021 · Answer: In the case of a desk rejection, authors are notified within the first few days. Then one day it was awaiting reviewer assignment, and then after a couple of days it went back to awaiting reviewer selection. Sep 15, 2020 · Hello, folks! I submitted my paper to IEEE EDL on September 6. Reviewer Invited: If the manuscript is suitable for peer review, this step indicates that the editor is searching for viable peer reviewers. As you may know, peer review can take a while, as peer reviewers do this along with their other work. Aug 4, 2018 · It then moved to ‘Awaiting reviewer selection’ and stayed at that stage for 9 days. Should I be worried? Is there anything I can do to accelerate this process? The problem is, I am planning to submit an adapted version of the manuscript as a book chapter. Jul 15, 2019 · 1 Answer to this question. So, you’ll probably know in the next few days. Most journals will try to catch this and either reject outright, or assign it to the same AE to handle. Unless desk rejected, Reject decisions may be based on a thorough single review. So, as mentioned previously, you may have reason to hope. Jan 31, 2024 · After a short time, the status of the manuscript changed to ‘Reviewer selection,’ then ‘Reviewer assignment’, then ‘Reviewer selection’, and then ‘Reviewer assignment’ again. I submitted a manuscript to a journal about a week ago (via ScholarOne). This status change occurs approximately every few days. It is almost 5 months since resubmission, but the status has remained “Awaiting Reviewer Selection” since then. For this example, we will edit the Reject status to enable ‘Review Visible to Authors. It occurs even before the peer review of the submitted manuscript begins. Does that mean desk rejection? Reviewer Assignment:The status "awaiting reviewer assignment" indicates that the editorial team is in the process of selecting and assigning new reviewers to evaluate your revised manuscript Nov 5, 2019 · However, finally he/she seems to have found the requisite number of reviewers and sent out review invitations to them. – Corvus Commented Mar 27, 2015 at 21:52 After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. I am afraid that after this long period, the editor will reject the manuscript. Now the status has changed to ‘Awaiting ED recommendation’. Nov 19, 2020 · Upon receipt of Reviewer Scores, the AE would normally make a judgment, based on the comments from the reviewers, to either accept or reject, outrightly or conditionally. What’s the deal with this? Otherwise, they will read the paper several more times, taking notes to build a detailed point-by-point review. e. You must write back to ensure it gets a proper review and you receive a detailed review report. The journal that originally recommended your transfer is the only one that can send you this email. Awaiting Reviewer Assignment: My status has changed from "Awaiting Reviewer Score" to Awaiting AE Decision". Just give it some time; either you will get a decision or it will go for the review process. I submitted a manuscript to a Sage Journal almost 50 days ago. The entire peer review process usually takes between 2 and 6 months. Desk rejection is a more likely outcome in such circumstances. Trying to divine why is a bad idea. Journal Evaluates the Reviews. This status is rather uncommon. Due to the situation necessitated by COVID-19, journal workflows and decision-making may have been impacted to some extent. Jan 29, 2023 · Desk reject after "awaiting reviewer selections" status. Dec 12, 2019 · I submitted my manuscript to a journal. It it is desk reject, then reviewer means the editor herself. It’s possible that the original review notice was internal, not external. That way, less reviewer time is wasted, and it would have a general downward effect on the number of publications that those grad students and post-docs could amass. Assisted desk rejects are rejections based on the judgment of the EiC or an AE that a paper is either out of scope or so far from acceptable as to make external reviews unnecessary. Recently, I have submitted a mathematical paper to a journal published by Taylor & Francis. Because ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ means that the manuscript passed the admin and/or Associate Editor (AE) check and was awaiting peer review. Also, one reviewer may send their comments on time or earlier, and the other(s) may take a while to get back. It said awaiting reviewer selection for 3 weeks. Desk-rejection (DR) is an important issue for all, authors and editors alike. what does this really mean? what is happening to my manuscript? Nov 30, 2020 · The manuscript being stuck at Awaiting Reviewer Assignment for a month is not uncommon. In the ‘Edit Status’ window, check the box, ‘Review Visible to Authors,’ and save the changes. 3. With the status of my current submission, I am worried whether it implies a desk rejection. ' However, just after a week (today, September 15), the status shows as 'Awaiting decision approval. So, one can’t really put a timeline to it. Sep 12, 2020 · Editors and journals take this rather seriously. What does this mean? Was the manuscript reviewed? I think the status should have changed to something like Awaiting Reviewer Scores before Awaiting EIC Decision. Should I Feb 26, 2021 · For further insights, you may go through this related query by another researcher: Why does my manuscript's status keep changing from "awaiting reviewer selection" to "awaiting reviewer assignment"? So, great. ' It has been a month now, but the status has not changed. Jun 5, 2017 · I think this journal uses the term 'under review' to refer to both internal and external review. Is it TMI allows reviewers three weeks – may be extended per request – to complete the review. Could the Associate Editor reject the manuscript at this stage? Nov 16, 2015 · A plausible guess is that the editorial software uses "awaiting reviewer selection" to mean that the manuscript has been received but has not been sent to a reviewer. Aug 3, 2021 · Dear Team, First, thank you for running such a stunning forum. It depends on whether the editor invites new reviewers. , by the editor without review). It was so for two months. Post Markup: Mar 13, 2022 · If the editorial management system (EMS) is distinguishing between the two, odds are "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" means the reviewers have not been invited yet, and "Awaiting Reviewer Confirmation" means the reviewers have not agreed to review the manuscript yet. What does that mean? Can it still get desk rejected? Jan 19, 2021 · After more than a year of passing through review > major review > review > minor revision > review, the status has been ‘Awaiting EIC decision’ for the past 20 days. Of course, one cannot be sure, but the status changes seem to indicate a higher possibility of a desk rejection, that is, a rejection without peer review. What the "awaiting reviewer scores" most plausibly Admin Dashboard （管理者ダッシュボード）に表示される査読プロセス中の論文ステータスは以下の通りです。 If it's SF, just forget about it for at least 6 months. ACM permits both desk (or bench) rejects and "assisted” desk rejects. On the occasion that a reviewer withdraws from the process, the Editorial Team will begin the reviewer selection process again. If it is not a desk reject, then it will surely go to the external peer-reviewers for review. So, please give me advice. "Awaiting reviewer invitation" should strictly be a very brief status, since the time between the editor deciding to invite reviewers and the editor actually inviting reviewers should be very brief, on the order of a few minutes. 2. what does it mean? DE has not distributed the paper to associate editor? or DE handles the paper by himself? thanks Probably means it will be desk rejected if it did not go out to reviewers. Nov 19, 2020 · I submitted an article to a ScholarOne journal. Awaiting Editor Decision Mar 6, 2019 · The status “Awaiting reviewer selection” seems to indicate that the manuscript cleared the initial editorial screening. Now the status is changed to "awaiting reviewer selection". (‘Referee’ is another term for ‘peer reviewer. ’ But this could be because the associate editor (AE) may have had a challenge finding reviewers for your manuscript. I was disappointed sure, but more annoyed because no reason was given at all (verbatim email with redactions): I am sorry to tell you that we will not be able to publish your paper titled "TITLE. Jul 30, 2019 · But if the status changes to “Decision in process” right after the initial screening, then it unfortunately means that the manuscript will be desk-rejected. Jul 12, 2022 · On July 12 the status was Awaiting AE Assignment Awaiting EIC Decision Does it mean rejection? I submitted my paper on June 24 and after few comments from the admin on the paper files I resubmitted the paper. Feb 14, 2023 · Is it possible to get a desk reject after the "awaiting reviewer selection" stage? Clearly it is, as your example illustrates. R: Responses on the format evaluation are sent to the authors in up to two business days. " Reviewer invited: Reviewers (commonly ≥ 3) have been invited to review your paper. For example, if two reviewers have engaged with your manuscript but a third reviewer has not been secured, or if a reviewer was secured but had to withdraw and hasn’t yet been replaced Or, a reviewer might recommend rejection based primarily on a legitimate shortcoming for which another member of the review team might propose a workable solution. Instead, they reject it outright based on an initial assessment. Finally, the status now is awaiting final decision since a week. Peer review scores have been sent to the editor and the status is awaiting editor decision for almost 4 weeks now. For an article that is going through the double blind review, we estimate a period of three months for the reports to be sent to the author(s). What can this mean? The platform is scholarone. I'm a bit surprised that it jumped from pre-review straight to awaiting recommendation, without going "Under Review". That's been my experience there also. Nov 24, 2021 · After revising and resubmit an article (the first peer review result was "minor revisions"), the status changed after 3 weeks to "Awaiting Decision". As you just wrote to them and the status has only recently changed, you may wait for some time to know the final decision. Also, keep in mind rejection rate without review in your journal. Assisted desk rejects may involve obtaining one outside Sep 15, 2020 · Hello, folks! I submitted my paper to IEEE EDL on September 6. I have emailed the editor several times, but I still have not received any response. This change has occurred Does the status 'Awaiting Reviewer Selection' mean that the manuscript has passed desk rejection by the editor? Now, an editorial management has to somehow summarise that you are waiting for this step. Reject: The paper has been through the peer review process and the Mar 16, 2022 · "Awaiting EIC decision" means that the journal is waiting on a decision by the "Editor in Chief". The status has not changed to ‘Under review’. However, if the status before this was “awaiting reviewer selection”, it implies that the manuscript has successfully cleared the editorial screening stage and now the editorial board is in process of finding suitable peer reviewers for your paper. However, the duration of an individual submission may vary drastically because there are many stochastic factors involved in the review process. The editor in chief may not just 'accept' or 'reject' the manuscript. Jul 19, 2018 · My paper was submitted to a ScholarOne journal and the submission status changed in the following way: "Awaiting review assignment" for 2 weeks, "Awaiting AE recommendation" for 1 week, and now it is "Awaiting SE decision. This means the initial check on the manuscript is complete, which means that the Editor-in-Chief (EiC) and/or the Associate Editor (AE) believe/s the manuscript fulfills basic journal criteria such as novelty of the research, quality of the writing, match with the journal’s scope Feb 12, 2014 · Journal editors could address this problem through increasing the percentage that they desk-reject (reject before sending out to review). If it is low, then it more likely to be already after review. Once enough reviewers have been selected, the manuscript will move on to the next stage. Apr 23, 2020 · So, we have made some edits/assumptions. Has anyone had this experience Mar 29, 2024 · "Awaiting ED Decision" would suggest that a decision is pending on your manuscript, which may not be a rejection - but in fact could be a suggestion to revise and resubmit, or even an acceptance. TMI’s average turnaround time, from initial submission to decision, is about 7-weeks. If the status is listed as Under Review it may still be desk rejected, but if it changes to Awaiting Reviewer Selection or Awaiting Reviewer Scores it has passed desk review, although it can still then be rejected on the basis of reviewer reports. The status showed as 'Awaiting ED decision. However, in some cases, it may not be a complete reject. ’ Go to the Settings tab and select Features>Paper Status. Also known as: with reviewers, with referees, under review, awaiting referee assignment, awaiting referee reports, awaiting reviewer scores, awaiting reviewer invitation , reviewers assigned, manuscript assigned to peer-reviewer/s (NPG) The initial selection of referees is usually comprised in the previous step. It is slightly strange that the status changed to “awaiting Ed decision” in a week’s time. Does this mean it has crossed desk reject 2 years ago # QUOTE 2 GOOD 1 NO GOOD! Reply. It is indeed not rare to get desk rejection after several weeks. Nov 13, 2017 · In general, reject with resubmission is equivalent to a major revision in other journals; i. If the paper is to be rejected at this point, a rejection letter is sent out and the file is closed. To maintain an effective Sage Track database of active reviewers we recommend that you: Awaiting reviewer selection EMERALD. It means nothing. The status changed to awaiting reviewer selection, and then changed to awaiting reviewer scores. Auto-Enabling Camera-Ready Feb 17, 2021 · Desk reject after "awaiting reviewer selections" status Hot Network Questions Fantasy book I read in the 2010s about a teen boy from a civilisation living underground with crystals as light sources Oct 24, 2018 · I just submitted a revised paper to ScholarOne (major revision). Sociologist 95d. Does it mean that it is past the desk rejection? 11 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod! Economist 0d24. Feb 18, 2022 · Awaiting Reviewer Selection. – Oct 6, 2021 · This means that the manuscript has been sent for peer review and the peer review has likely been completed, and now the journal is awaiting the final scores from the reviewer/s. More specifically, though: You are looking for all sorts of formal reasons why the paper might have been rejected, or maybe why they wrongly rejected it. ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ means that your manuscript has cleared the desk screening and is now ready to be sent for peer review. The status has been awaiting DE decision for more than a month since the third day of submission. I am really confused, can I contact the journal to explain this or should I just wait? If they do reject it without review, that week delay the paper was probably on the AE's to-do list. This is the first stage of the peer-review process and your manuscript will be here until the assigned Editor has selected some suitable experts to invite to review. thanks a lot. xgwvwnqh fqei musnv kct psinfg siqkpf rijf htclur mqbnchi ehoa